Thursday, July 27, 2006

Execution Alerts

Eleven people are scheduled to be killed by the state in August (four in Texas, for whatever that's worth). It's the standard situation. People who lived horrible, horrible lives and had terrible things done to them turned around and perpetrated dreadful crimes. The condemned prisoners include the mentally ill and at least one mentally retarded person. You can read about each of the condemned prisoners here: NCADP. Only recently have we stopped executing juvenile offenders. Go here to read about the Supreme Court decision that changed our public policy. Among other things it admits that we had been in violation of several international treaties while it was our practice. We have executed people so mentally ill they couldn't understand that they were about to die. We have executed people whose attorneys slept through their trials.

So, it's not exactly a big intellectual leap to claim that we do this punishment thing badly. It's a certainty that we've had the wrong people on death row. It's almost certain that we've actually executed the wrong person; do a google search for Ruben Cantu if you want to know more. But if- through some miracle- we could execute perfectly, never getting it wrong, having it be more cost effective than life imprisonment, eliminating the racial bias, and only executing the competent.... would it then be all right?

It's hard to wrap my brain around that. Surely, the answer isn't killing better. The answer is being better. Being bigger. Having more integrity than the criminals who wreak such havoc in people's lives.

Wednesday, July 26, 2006

Going WAY out on a limb here

We default to a pro-Israel position in this country and I guess I'm okay with that. But it seems to me that Israel is in danger of using up its political capital in this aggression with Lebanon. I can already hear other leftie-types yelling at me, but I think it's something worth exploring. Perhaps this time, we ought not support what Israel is doing.

It's hard to claim that hundreds of Lebanese deaths -most of them civilians- are a proportional response to the capture of the two Israeli soldiers. And the number of refugees being created by this war (that must have a reason other than the captured soldiers) is overwhelming international aid agencies, which already had plenty to do.

There's some evidence (from the United Nations and other aid groups) that Israel is using illegal weapons that kill indiscriminately. Which sort of seems obvious when you think about it. Otherwise, the much-vaunted Israeli army is full of dreadfully poor tacticians. They can't claim that they are targeting combatants and just making tragic errors while simultaneously claiming to be some sort of super-army. It's much more likely that they are a super-army and are accomplishing exactly what they set out to do.

And WHAT is the unwillingness to negotiate about, pray tell.

Of course, I have absolutely no idea what any of us might do about this situation, any more than I know what to do about George Bush floating the test balloon of "Iran is the unseen manipulator behind all this". Yeah, George.... your unseen causes of other wars have worked out really well for us. Surely though, all the parties could be held accountable to the rule of international law. And I'm completely willing to believe that there are more than two parties. I'm just not convinced that the third one is so conveniently Iran. I think the third party might be the United States. After all, Israel is fighting with weapons they got from us and certainly encouragement for Israel to keep bombing is coming from the White House.

Tuesday, July 25, 2006

What ought to be on trial....

Were I queen, it wouldn't be Andrea Yates on trial for the deaths of those poor children. I've stated my case on this subject before -and better than I'm feeling capable of this morning: Is This God's Will for Women?. At the very least, the social commentary (since I have no legal qualifications of any sort) ought to be about the consequences -for all of us- of these extremely conservative surrendered-wife kind of relationships.

Since I wrote that first piece, I've done a smidge of reading about this issue. It does seem clear that there are religious variations in the prevalence of domestic violence; men who hold much more conservative religious beliefs than their female partners are more likely to be violent (Ellison, Bartkowski, and Anderson, in case you care). Abused women who are members of conservative evangelical churches are more likely to define themselves as "bad" than as abused (Stotland) and it's well-documented that abusers can find allies in conservative churches. Let's assume in some twisted way they mean well or are operating from ignorance rather than malice, but pastors are notorious for blaming the victim, for encouraging ineffective forms of counseling, for assigning great stigma to the dissolution of an abusive relationship, and for interrupting the victim's relationships with health-care providers.

And historically, the evidence seems to suggest that we wouldn't care if the victims were "only" women. But do we really need more evidence that children are also injured by this kind of relationship? I'm a little dissatisfied with my own hysteria on this subject. I do think that Rusty Yates is also guilty in this tragedy. I certainly think that his views are a misuse of religion. But I can't believe that we can juridically do away with that kind of religious expression. Nor can we (social workers and other health care providers) prohibit someone from having children when, in our hearts, we know it's not a good idea. That way lies madness, for sure. But might there not be some kind of legal recourse when religion is so clearly complicit in a tragedy like this?

Or is the only solution for those of us who are also religious to model relationships that are healthy, joyous, and strong? And why does that not feel like enough to me? And here's another thing. Why can't I find a study that looks at depression in fundamentalist households? Religiosity is largely a buffer for depression, but I'm curious to know if there's a difference in the incidence and prevalence of depression among conservative, mainstream, and progressive forms of religious expression. Can't find it. That seems weird.

Monday, July 24, 2006

Car-Free Life? Can We do it?

Brace yourself for more existential angst. I took the car in for an oil change. AN OIL CHANGE. Oh, and while you have it, I need to drive it a lot in the coming weeks, so please make sure I'm not going to die somewhere between here and Nowheresville, Alabama. $2500 later, we have ... something that I don't know what it is. Something to do with the wheel and something to do with emissions.

Naturally, this started us down the path of questioning whether or not we could be a car-free family again. The long-suffering spouse could do it tomorrow and not feel any pain or regret at all. In fact, he'd be thrilled. I would be less thrilled. This is a town with tragically limited public transportation within the city and essentially no public transportation to surrounding towns. Right now, I'm very willing to ride my bike, but this town is also bloody cold and snowy and windy in the winter. Bike-riding is a LOT less attractive then.

And things do arise. See the previous post. Yes, I CAN ride my bike to Beloit and back in one day. But it greatly increases the time and energy that trips like that one take. And, for many and varied professional reasons, the long-suffering spouse and I will be living in separate towns, states, and possibly continents next year. So maybe this isn't the best year to ditch the car.

But I did go this far. In an effort to live simply with the earth and to reduce our dependence on fossil-fuels and our complicity with the car-culture, I'm willing to start off with one car-free day a week. It will just mean that errands requiring the car get consolidated into one or two days, but that's more efficient in any case. Maybe the goal is that eventually we could be car-free. Maybe. As the math-guy worked out, we could rent a car almost as frequently as once a week for the errands and crises that arise and still save money over owning our own car.

But I'm not going there yet. I am committed to one car-free day a week. That's going to be hard enough!

Sunday, July 23, 2006

My Ass is Dragging

Well, if you know me, you know that that's almost literally true, but what I MEAN is, it's been a hard weekend. Which is all by way of explaining the light and variable blogging activity.

A friend had abdominal surgery for what was almost certain to be ovarian cancer. Turns out it isn't, thank heavens. But she still had surgery. So we went up to Beloit this weekend to take care of her, and for Dave to ride bikes with her husband so that he could have a fun break too. It was just the kind of "babysitting" that friends occasionally do for friends, and they've certainly done for us over the years.

Then, we arrive back home, and it turns out that the neighbor has had a heart attack in our driveway, pretty literally five minutes before. The ambulance has taken him to a hospital in another town for an angiogram, but they've confirmed the EMTs' theory that it really was a heart attack. This man is possibly 40, maybe not quite, and athletic and trim. He also has a father with Alzheimer's and two autistic sons. So, there's a little bit of stress in his life. Think good thoughts for that family, and calm nurturing thoughts as the neighbors and family take turns caring for these dear, challenged little boys during a difficult time.

Where's the peppermint schnapps? I think it would be medicinal right about now.

Friday, July 21, 2006

Friday Random 10


You know the drill. Take out your iPod and set it to shuffle mode. Tell us the first ten songs that play -and no fair leaving out the ones that make you look like a dork. Dorkiness is my typical state of affairs, so... here's my list.

  • Disobey; Kate Havevnik (from my Uppity Women playlist)
  • I Wanna Feel That Way Again; Tracy Bird (Oh dear. This is from my Heart-Broken Cowboys; Fun-Loving Cowgirls playlist. I won't subject you to the rest of it.)
  • Sweet Dreams; Emmylou Harris (Lullabies playlist)
  • Piano Concerto No. 2 in F Minor, Larghetto; Chopin via Emanual Ax (in a generic piano music playlist)
  • Suite in D Major, "Air on a G String"; Bach (Sappy Classical Music playlist)
  • Girl on a Bicycle; Ralph McTell (I Want to Ride My Bicycle playlist)
  • King of the Road; Elvis Presley (essential in my Running Errands playlist)
  • I Could Have Danced All Night; Rosemary Clooney (Chick Flicks playlist)
  • Closer to Fine; Indigo Girls (Rebel with a Clue playlist)
  • May This Be Love; Emmylou Harris (Down from the Mountain playlist)


Wednesday, July 19, 2006

What Are You Reading?



It's happened again. I have no book. I go to the bookstore and nothing jumps off the shelf and comes home with me. So, I need help.

Books I've read recently (almost always at the behest of others -HOW do you people keep up with this stuff???) and enjoyed include:
  • The Inner Quarters: Marriage and the Lives of Chinese Women in the Sung Dynasty by Patricia Ebrey. It sounds more erudite than it was; it wasn't a dry read at all.
  • The Dance of the Dissident Daughter by Sue Monk Kidd -definitely worth a read
  • A Year by the Sea: Thoughts of an Unfinished Woman by Joan Anderson. Her husband goes away on sabbatical for a year and she can't/won't go with him. Sound familiar?
  • The Brief History of the Dead by Kevin Brockmeier- It's part thriller and part testament to the importance of memory. It's really good, if by that we mean that you keep thinking about it long after you've put it down.


So, what ideas do you have for me? I'm a desperate woman. Has anyone read Jimmy Carter's new book, Our Endangered Values? Check out this list for a wildly ethnocentric life-time reading plan. I'm afraid that, having been to one of those Great Books (must be capitalized and said in sonorous tones) colleges, this will not serve as an emergency reading plan. I'm only missing two or three books, and I know -I mean I really KNOW- that I can't make it through Pilgrim's Progress. It can't be done.

Tuesday, July 18, 2006

What Do You Think?

It's been almost a year using the other format, and I was in the mood for a change. Having done this blogging thing for a while now, I know a little more about what I need/want for my own blog. A three-column format springs to mind, for example. Delayed/automatic posting is another feature I'd like. Probably I'm going to switch to typepad in the near future, but I'm waiting for my friend Mike to get home from vacation. He uses typepad and I want to pick his brain. This color change will tide me over, in the meantime.

I have lost the old comments, and I'm very sorry about that. They were/are important to me, so keep them coming, please! Now off to get my links and sidebar into shape. I didn't need to work out this evening ;)

Sentence Carried Out

William Downs was executed in South Carolina on July 14.

There is no way to argue that he was innocent. There's no way to claim that he did anything other than inflict horrible pain on a child and the child's family. I can barely find place in my heart to pity him.

But he still shouldn't have been killed. Killing him diminishes all of us. We become not just killers ourselves, but killers of the mentally ill.

You can find an indifferently written blog entry from one of the media witnesses to the execution here: WLTX. It's worth reading, just to learn more about how and why executions are covered by the press. There is no mention of Down's "guilty but mentally ill" conviction. There's no mention of the reactions of the observers. There's no mention of whether or not the family of his victim found any peace in the process. There is a brief mention of the fact that Down's sister is the one who turned him into the police. She was there to watch the execution. Now, there's a story -not that I'd be willing to tell it, in her shoes. But can you imagine the emotional turmoil? I can hardly stand to think about it.

Truth, justice, and the American way.... is there anything meritorious about the American way, anymore? I don't feel anything other than small and cheapened.

Monday, July 17, 2006

Women in Hate Groups

I'm having a hard time wrapping my brain around an experience from this weekend. A little town nearby (within biking distance, which is how I know about it) was "treated" to an anti-immigrant rally led by an all-female white supremacist group. There were only 4 of them -people, not groups- so it doesn't seem as though, at least locally, this phenomenon of women in hate groups is catching on. But why did the very fact of it surprise me?

The whole thing was confusing, actually. To begin with, it was an anti-immigrant rally rather than an anti-immigration rally. Surely I'm not the only one who sees the difference. The first one is anti-specific people; the second one is against a specific policy. I'm not crazy about either version, but the first certainly seems to have an undertone of violence.

Then there were the approximately 100 counter-protesters. What a great opportunity, in the face of a hate group, to be different -to model integrity while standing up for what is right. Or not. Tempers were clearly frayed, even though the groups were well apart from each other. Ad hominem attacks... threats.... and this from the people protesting hate groups. It made me very sad, and also a little worried for the peace movement. (Is there actually a peace movement, anymore?) Those of us of a certain age actually went to trainings about how to protest peacefully. We need to resurrect the training, apparently, or people need to avail themselves of it.

And then there were the four women, representatives of Aryan Anarchist Skins. What would inspire anyone to join a hate group, is certainly a relevant question. But I'm always particularly perplexed when a member of a persecuted group wants to join. And it gets more complicated. An unusual feature of this particular group is that it's gay-friendly. Apparently, white supremacist groups are almost uniformly anti-gay. So now we have two layers of oppression to wade through. Well, maybe we do. The members are certainly women and possibly one or more of them is lesbian. I don't know that just from their stated policy of being gay-friendly, obviously. But it's certainly true that other hate groups are not supporting this particular hate group because they're not quite hateful enough towards gay people. So, these four women are apparently willing to be the only four people on the planet standing for their beliefs. They're willing to be hated by the peace-groups. They're willing to be hated by the hate groups. And all in the service of hating some more. Is anyone else's brain melting?

Certainly they have a Constitutional right to hate all they want and to tell us all about it. But the rest of us have a parallel right, of course. In case anyone locally is worried about someone's potential involvement in a hate group, there are ample materials that help to prevent recruitment of young people into racist groups. The Anti-Defamation League recommends a brochure for young people called, Close the Book on Hate: 101 Ways to Combat Prejudice. It is available through the Anti-Defamation League website and at Barnes and Noble. Tolerance.org also offers practical steps on how to respond to bigoted comments through its 10 Ways to Fight Hate.

Saturday, July 15, 2006

Pon de Replay

A while ago, I wrote about Rep. Steve King (R-IA) and his embarrassing lack of intellect and the absence of reason in his decisions. You can find it here: Pro-Life, at What Cost?. Who knew that this guy was going to turn into a fixture of American life and dark comedy?

Apparently, he's designed an electrified fence that could be strung along the U.S.-Mexico border. In case we didn't get the idea, he actually built a prototype on the floor of the House, explaining as he did:
I also say we need to do a few other things on top of that wall, and one of them being to put a little bit of wire on top here to provide a disincentive for people to climb over the top or put a ladder there. We could also electrify this wire with the kind of current that would not kill somebody, but it would simply be a discouragement for them to be fooling around with it. We do that with livestock all the time."


He sees no irony here... no problem in thinking that we would treat people as we treat livestock. I guess this shouldn't surprise me from a man who thinks McCarthy was a great American hero and that illegal immigrants are responsible for the deaths of 25 Americans every day. I was expecting, perhaps, intellectual agility?

Friday, July 14, 2006

Friday Random 10


You know the drill. Take out your iPod and set it to shuffle mode. Tell us the first ten songs that appear. And no fair leaving out the ones that make you look like a dork or adding in ones that make you look cool. Since there's essentially no chance of the latter....

  • Oh Had I a Golden Thread; Judy Collins
  • Sheep May Safely Graze; J.S. Bach
  • Runaway; The Corrs
  • I Wish; Kathy Phillips
  • Make Someone Happy; Jimmy Durante
  • Highland Cathedral; Royal Scots Dragoon Guards
  • Witchcraft; Frank Sinatra
  • When Nothing Satisfies; Jennifer Knapp
  • Relating to a Psychopath; Macy Gray
  • Trip Around the Sun; Al Anderson


Thursday, July 13, 2006

A Woman's Place

In the interest of full disclosure I should tell you that I was educated at girls' schools all of my pre-college life, and I have a real soft spot for them. I see the ideological concerns, but for me girls' schools were (and are) the source of my feminism and my sense of power as a person on the planet. So, there's that.

And a little background information re: girls' schools in developing countries. For every year of education after the 4th grade that a girl earns, her later income rises 20% over the previous year. (Would that it were true in this country and that the benefit continued as far as graduate school. I'd be SO rich!!) Moreover, infant mortality decreases markedly for each year of education that a girl gets and family health indicators improve. If you want healthier families, educate women. It's really that simple. (There are citations for this. I'll track them down. If I can just get people to stop calling me.)

But no..... In Afghanistan, burnings of girls' schools and the killing of teachers are increasing at an alarming rate as the Taliban resurgence continues to gain strength. Under the Taliban regime, education for Afghan women and girls was banned. Attacks on girls' schools began immediately following the re-opening of the schools by the new Afghan government in 2002, but the current situation has reached crisis proportions, undermining the rights that Afghan women and girls were just beginning to enjoy.

Many children, especially girls, are kept home out of their parents' fear for their safety. In Lessons in Terror: Attacks on Education in Afghanistan, a report just released by Human Rights Watch, it becomes clear that in some areas of Afghanistan the majority of primary-school-age girls do not attend school at all and only 5% of girls (compared to an uninspiring 20 percent for boys) attend secondary schools. Human Rights Watch has called for the international community and the Afghan government to develop a concrete strategy for addressing the security problems of children trying to attend school.

The United Nations has also repeatedly condemned the attacks on schools. The World Food Program recently issued a report raising concerns about these increases in threats and attacks on girls' schools. Munoz Villalobos, the UN Special Rapporteur on the right to education said in his recent statement "I am deeply concerned that schools, especially girls' schools, seem to be systematically targeted by terrorist groups with the apparent objective of forcing parents to refrain from sending their children to school and thus forcing the authorities to close the schools."

The Feminist Majority has waged a campaign urging the U.S. to increase security in Afghanistan, to protect the rights of women and girls, and to increase funding for organizations working to advance women's rights in Afghanistan and Afghan women-led non-profits. Eleanor Smeal, President of the Feminist Majority Foundation/Feminist Majority said, "As the bombings and burning of girls' schools continue unabated and the situation for women and girls continues to deteriorate, the Bush Administration remains silent."

Well, who's surprised by that? But there is a glimmer of hope. The Afghan Women's Empowerment Act of 2006 would authorize $30 million a year for three years for non-profits to provide education for children as well as adult literacy and vocational training. Follow the link for more information and don't forget to urge your Senators and Representative to support the bill, if you are so inclined. After the "read more" goes here.

Wednesday, July 12, 2006

For Everyone's Good... Spy On Your Neighbors????

We were supposed to do it after September 11, remember? Just in case the little old lady next door was a closet terrorist in between bouts of cookie making. She did chase my children with a broom one day, so maybe I should report her. Of course, the kids were picking her flowers, so it's a tough call. Maybe it's my kids who were the terrorists. You never know.

We already have at least one publicly-accessible list of the criminal behavior of our neighbors. You can go to the website for your state government and find out where convicted sex offenders live. Honestly, I don't know how I feel about this. I want to protect children. I know that true sexual predators don't get better. But I haven't looked to see if there are any such people in my neighborhood. I find the fact that I could know vaguely unsettling.

Now the state of Tennessee has launched a website where you can track your neighbors convicted of methamphetamine offenses. Yes, meth is a drug that truncates people's lives. Yes, it's dangerous. Must we track the people who've done their time forever, in order to feel safe? And really, the tempest about meth labs has always struck me as a diversionary tactic from policy makers who don't know what to do about health care or education or any of a host of thorny problems.

And then, continuing the enforcement-first strategy popularized by our President, there are vigilante groups with websites tracking people they think might be illegal immigrants. I can give you a link, but I really don't want to inflate their statistics. Try a google search on "NoInvaders"; you'll find it.

And all of this begs the question. How normal must our neighbors be? How un-scary? How like us must they be, before we start to worry and make lists and plot public humiliation and vigilante strategies? Can we not find any space for tolerance anymore?

Actually there's a bigger question. What have we become?

Tuesday, July 11, 2006

Can You Hear Me Now?

Look in your pocket. Is that a Verizon phone you're carrying around? 42 million people would answer yes. The problem is that Verizon isn't winning any ethical prizes lately, especially when it comes to employment practices.

Here's the story, according to a Federal Administrative Law Judge:
  • The company has prohibited workers from talking about the union on their own time;
  • A company rule requires employees to report all union activity at their worksite, as part of the company's national "Emergency Procedures;"
  • And, in an action reminiscent of Wal-Mart's closure of a Quebec store when its employees formed a union, Verizon Wireless shut down a call center after its employees moved closer to getting a union.


And besides, they gave phone records to the NSA. Maybe we should just hang up on them.

According to the New York Times, Cingular, Verizon's top competitor, does honor its employees wishes to unionize. Working Assets seems like it would be a good choice, but they too have been accused of anti-consumer practices. Here's a link to an evaluation of various wireless service providers: BuyBlue. Unfortunately, it's kind of discouraging. What would you do?

Whether or not you're a Verizon customer... whether or not you intend to change your service provider, you can encourage Verizon Wireless to acknowledge that fiar employment practices are good business. Their employees deserve a say in their working conditions and some job security. You could drop a line to them here: The Petition Site.




Monday, July 10, 2006

Executions in Our Name

On July 14, William Downs is scheduled to be executed in South Carolina. He pled guilty to the rape and murder of a 6-year-old boy, in 2002. The idea of a 6-year-old suffering like that just makes me want to spit nails.

But here's the thing. William Downs tried to commit suicide while in pre-trial custody. He waived his right to a jury trial (in a capital case!) and refused to allow his lawyer to present mitigating evidence. He was found to be "guilty but mentally ill", which in South Carolina does not preclude the possibility of execution.

Can we really execute the mentally ill? Really???? And still be recognizably sane ourselves? Possibly charity toward a person who would commit such a crime is beyond me. I really don't know. But for me -for us- for the principle of the thing, damn it- we can't execute people who can not control their behavior.

If you agree, you might try writing to Mark Sanford, the governor of South Carolina, There's a sample letter here: Amnesty International.

Sunday, July 09, 2006

No Other Love? Really???

I woke up this morning to NPR telling me that the Pope blasted gay marriage while he was in Spain. Sigh. It wouldn't surprise me if he did. Nor would it surprise me, however, if NPR got it wrong.

What the Pope really said, in part, was
I ask your prayer for all families, that they will live in accordance with their God-given vocation and benefit from just governmental policies that safeguard their fundamental role in society
So far, so good, actually. Certainly, this doesn't rule out the possibility of covenantal marriages between partners of the same sex.

But this is Joseph Ratzinger, so we'd better not jump to conclusions. He also said,
marital union [is] between a man and a woman according to the plans of the creator
and
If we are to encourage the family, help it fulfill its commitments, we must work for social cohesion and, above all, respect its rights which cannot be dissolved by other kinds of unions that seek to replace it.


Oh, just knock it off. The Pope may be reactionary and a pain in the nether regions, but he's not stupid. He sees that that's not an argument that makes any sense. I've read nothing about gay marriage that says that the goal is to replace marriage between two people of different genders. All anyone wants is a broader definition of covenant. Moreover, look at that last sentence. Is he really claiming that my rights as a married person would be somehow diminished or even eliminated (he says "dissolved") by sharing the marital definition with people who do it differently?

So this covenant that no one's arguing that my partner and I have -this covenant that involves God, if one believes the church's understanding of covenant- is so fragile that broadening the definition of who's included would destroy it? That's a very weak God. Or a very uninvolved one, I suppose.

The internally consistent argument that they could -and do- make is that neither the couple nor society is the author of marriage. God is. And we fully understand and comply with what God said about it. I'm with them right up to the last bit. That's not how revelation works. We understand God's revealed intentions for us as we are capable. We gain more understanding with maturity and through grace. Seriously, what precludes the possibility that we didn't get it right when we said that marriage was exclusively between a man and a woman? It seemed reasonable at the time, perhaps, but now we know more. Let's celebrate that and move on.

What am I missing here?

Friday, July 07, 2006

Friday Random 10


You know the drill. Take out your iPod and set it to shuffle mode. Tell us the first ten songs that play -and no fair leaving out ones that make you look like a dork or adding in ones you think will make you look cool.

Here are mine this week:
  • Lord of the Cradle -our church choir, rehearsing
  • Who'll Stop the Rain; Creedence Clearwater Revival
  • I Will Never Let You Go; Jackie Greene (from the Brokeback Mountain soundtrack. Get this CD. Really!)
  • Jerusalem, My Destiny; Still Pointe
  • I Give You the Morning; Tom Paxton (possibly the most romantic folk song ever)
  • Blue Bayou; Roy Orbison
  • Fantasia for Lute; Weiss via Andre Segovia
  • One Good Year; Slaid Cleaves
  • Rain and Snow; The Be Good Tanyas
  • Morning Dew/ Women of Ireland; The Chieftains


Thursday, July 06, 2006

The 100-Mile Diet

Okay, I couldn't do this on a regular basis, I don't think, but you know that I try to live sustainably and gently with the earth. Some days are better than others. I read about the 100-mile diet on David Suzuki's website; the challege of course is to eat food that grew within 100 miles of your house. Doing so supports local farmers, reduces toxic emissions, and can (but doesn't necessarily) reduce the amount of pesticides going into your body. Besides, you get to meet and chat with the people who grew the food. They feel about food the way I feel about yarn. They love their work and they love to talk about it. This is the time of year to give this way of eating a shot, and Thursdays are Farmer's Market days here in corn-town. So off I went on the little red bicycle, with my basket and a grocery list.

I came home with NOTHING on the list. Wonderful things, but nothing on the list. I have new potatoes, and flowers, and salsa, and asparagus, and blueberries, and scallions. I have home-made soap and home-made wine. Now... I challenge anyone to come up with a dinner from that. We had twice-baked potatoes with salsa on top, asparagus on the side, and blueberry cobbler for dessert. So I guess I did come up with a dinner, but it was a little catch-as-catch-can.

Anyway.... I have no point, really. It's just that I'm still looking for ways to live gently and simply, and sometimes those ways are right under my nose.

Wednesday, July 05, 2006

Okay, I hear this sometimes...

and I heard it three times this past weekend. It was a four-day weekend of lazing about for us -except we're not good at lazing, exactly. But we gave it a shot.

I spent my time more or less as follows: I took apart and put back together a bridesmaid dress for Victoria so she could wear it in a wedding on Sunday and have it remain on her body. So for a few days, there were miles of turquoise satin spread out all over the dining room. Alarming, but there was method to my madness. The problem, though, is that if you pop over for a visit, there's no avoiding the dining room. And fabric pieces draped over chairs, lamps, and people who hold still long enough will probably get your attention. Which generated several versions of "You SEW? How traditional. How...charming." Okay, whatever....

The dress gets put back together. Victoria walks down the aisle (GACK) and totally steals the show from the bride. But that's another story -and possibly I'm biased, anyway. The next day I spent knitting in public. I had taken my beloved iPod to Starbucks to knit and catch up on work-related podcasts. Were people impressed with my ability to simultaneously listen, think, drink coffee, and knit? Apparently not. But they think knitting is...quaint. If only they had the time....

Then yesterday, the long-suffering spouse and I went tramping around at Starved Rock State Park. We wanted to be there most of the day, so I packed food. Which I cooked. Big deal. If you like to eat, eventually you learn to cook, don't you? OK, by accident, I swear, we were also sitting on a picnic tablecloth that I made and my knitting was with us. The comment this time was "Your husband is a lucky man." Well, yes ;) But not because I COOK, for heaven's sake. Which I thought, but didn't say.

OK, so what is going on here? I don't do any of these traditional crafts (arts?) because I have to. My family will be clothed and fed whether or not I sew, knit, garden, or cook. Moreover, I have the free time and disposable income to do them. If I were a single mother, making minimum wage, and working 60 hours a week, I wouldn't be knitting. If I had a spare moment, I'd be sleeping, thank you very much. So, far from being a necessity, these acts are expensive luxuries. But I don't want to be stuck with the argument that these activities I love are just another version of conspicuous consumption and classism. So let's move along.

I'd much rather make an argument that I do these things because of my feminism rather than in spite of it. Here's how it feels when I'm in the middle of one of these crafty-activities. I spend a lot of time immersed in the ugliness that people inflict on each other. I don't mind. Actually, I like helping people move past the ugliness and make something beautiful. There it is. This is my version of making something beautiful. Everyone needs and deserves to move past the mundane. Certainly, I don't need everyone to knit or bake, but I would hope that creating beauty -touching it, making it, BEING it- would be a part of everyone's life.

That's my argument and I'm sticking to it.

Monday, July 03, 2006

The Death Penalty Makes Us All Murderers

Today is the 30th anniversary of the re-instatement of the death penalty in this country. You know, or have access to, all the data points that you need. How many people are on death row, the racial bias, the inept trials, the number of people exonerated, the number of people killed and then posthumously exonerated....We can not get this right. I don't mean that we haven't yet. I mean that a right and fair way for the state to execute people in my name can not, by definition, be found.

We can -and must- remember the victims, but it ought not be with more killing. Moreover, we need to remember the victims' families. By and large, these people are invisible to us, and yet they suffer the consequences of the murder forever. If you're looking for ways to get involved, you might look at Murder Victims' Families for Human Rights. If you want to learn more about the issue, you could watch The Innocent, a documentary about innocent survivors of death row. I saw it in Chicago a few days ago, and it's really worth watching. It's not easy, heaven knows, but it is worthwhile. Or you read Sr. Helen Prejean's new book The Death of Innocents. I haven't read it yet, myself, so I'm counting on someone to report back.

And we all need to watch what happens in Wisconsin this fall. They're considering a referendum to reinstate the death penalty after 153 years of not having it. Because it works so well everywhere else??? And we need to keep talking about this issue. It ought not be that this rite of revenge happens quietly, out of public view, and unchallenged.

Sunday, July 02, 2006

Crimes Against Humanity

Everybody knows that George Bush and White House policies re: Guantanamo received a significant smackdown last week. Time and past time for that! It seems to me, though, that a little piece of this decision is being under-reported. (Or I'm misunderstanding its significance.)

The Supreme Court held that the Geneva Conventions do apply to the "war on terror", specifically mentioning Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions. For the attention-reduced, here's the short form.
Article 3

In the case of armed conflict not of an international character occurring in the territory of one of the High Contracting Parties, each party to the conflict shall be bound to apply, as a minimum, the following provisions:
1. Persons taking no active part in the hostilities, including members of armed forces who have laid down their arms and those placed hors de combat by sickness, wounds, detention, or any other cause, shall in all circumstances be treated humanely, without any adverse distinction founded on race, colour, religion or faith, sex, birth or wealth, or any other similar criteria.

To this end the following acts are and shall remain prohibited at any time and in any place whatsoever with respect to the above-mentioned persons:
(a) Violence to life and person, in particular murder of all kinds, mutilation, cruel treatment and torture;
(b) Taking of hostages;
(c) Outrages upon personal dignity, in particular, humiliating and degrading treatment;
(d) The passing of sentences and the carrying out of executions without previous judgment pronounced by a regularly constituted court affording all the judicial guarantees which are recognized as indispensable by civilized peoples.

2. The wounded and sick shall be collected and cared for.

An impartial humanitarian body, such as the International Committee of the Red Cross, may offer its services to the Parties to the conflict.

The Parties to the conflict should further endeavour to bring into force, by means of special agreements, all or part of the other provisions of the present Convention.

The application of the preceding provisions shall not affect the legal status of the Parties to the conflict.


Now, doesn't that mean that absent compliance with the Conventions, President Bush and his cronies could be tried for war crimes? Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez is famous for referring to the Geneva Conventions as "quaint". Clearly, the White House still believes that, because they immediately started to look for Congressional work-arounds to avoid the consequences of the Court's decision.

The Justices also said that this decision says nothing about the future of Guantanamo itself. OK, I see that. But (and I'm no lawyer) the decision ruled that the Bush administration's decision to try the detainees at Guantanamo in military war trials is illegal. Presumably then, they must be tried either in federal court, in military courts martial, or the detainees would have to be repatriated and tried in their home countries. I'm actually wondering if this decision doesn't give the White House a graceful out re: closing the prison that has become a political liability. They could take the self-serving position that they tried to protect the people from the evil represented by these (untried and uncharged) people held in detention, but the Supreme Court tied their hands. They save face and the prison is closed.

And then some enterprising lawyers could set about the business of trying the entire administration for crimes against humanity.

Friday, June 30, 2006

Friday Random 10



Whew! An easy post!

You know the drill. Take out your iPod and set it to shuffle mode. Tell us the first ten songs that appear -and no fair leaving out ones that make you look like a dork or adding in ones that make you look cool. By now you all know that I have a peculiar mixture of really, truly good music and ...well, dreck. Here's this week's list:

  • Welcome in this Place; Hillsong (Sophie, you'd like this one.)
  • Mamiya: Five Finnish Folk Songs for Cello and Piano; Yo-Yo Ma and the Silk Road Ensemble
  • Kathy's Song; Simon & Garfunkle
  • Caught in the Crossfire; John McCutcheon
  • Viola Concerto in G (51: G9) -Allegro: Telemann via Florian Deuter
  • Born to Run; Bang!
  • My Father's Eyes; Eric Clapton
  • Leader of the Band; Dan Fogelberg
  • Ride Like the Wind; Christopher Cross
  • Empowered; David and Steve Gordon


And since I've been so boring lately, here's a bonus playlist. Riffing off someone else's idea (Sorry, I've long since forgotten whose.), I made a playlist called Sorry, Everybody -a musical apology to the world for what this country has become. Here's my list.

  • The Right Decision; World View
  • Make Up Your Mind; Orange park
  • The Great Discontent; Man on Earth
  • Who Would Jesus Bomb?: David Rovics
  • JesusLand; David Ippolito
  • Lies; Priscilla Herdman
  • Dirty Little War; Terry Tufts
  • What made America Famous>; Harry Chapin
  • Come On Home; Indigo Girls
  • Which Side Are You On?; Dick Gaughan
  • A Parcel of Rogues in a Nation; Jean Redpath
  • I AM a Patriot; Jackson Browne
  • Let's Impeach the President; Neil Young
  • Mr. President, Have Pity on the Working Man; Sam Bush
  • Oh Mary, Don't You Weep; Arlo Guthrie
  • With God On Our Side; Neville Brothers
  • Wartime Prayers; Paul Simon


It actually goes on a lot longer. I must have been really steamed when I put this one together!

Thursday, June 29, 2006

Going under for the third time?

OK, I'm in over my head. I have too much work to do, too little time to do it, and I need someone to stand up and be willing to take the blame for that. You don't have to be here or change anything about what you do. But when I get busted for all these unfinished projects, I want to be able to say "Oh, that's so-and-so's fault" where so-and-so is not me. Is that so much to ask?

What? No takers? Hard to believe....

Sigh.... I'll try to be in a better, slightly more profound (less un-profound), spot tomorrow. You never know. It could happen.

Wednesday, June 28, 2006

An Oil-Free Future?

Well, I doubt it. But I did my bit today, and that's the truth.

Today was the National Day of Action for an Oil-Free Congress. Went right by you, didn't it? I wouldn't call it a catchy title, exactly. The idea is that the Republicans are using the national distress over gas prices as an excuse for more give-aways to the oil companies rather than getting serious about cleaner fuels and alternatives to cars. Since 1990, oil companies have given more than $190 million to members of Congress -75% of that to Republicans. And it's certainly paid off for them in friendly-to-them energy policies.

So there were rallies at gas stations around the country today, witnessing to the possibility of a clean energy future. One of the rallies was around the corner and down the street from my house, so I hopped on the little red bicycle (the love of my life) and went to see what was going on. Not much -but I met some locally-causy people I hadn't met before. And in this town, that's no small feat. It's usually the same three causy people at all the events -and local readers of this blog can name them without much trouble.

And then, I sent e-mail to the manager of the bike store -not the love of my life, but he keeps the love of my life on the road, so he's pretty special to me ;)- with an e-mail link to the Minneapolis bicycle film festival. Now how cool is that? Biking and movies... two of my favorite things. And he wrote back, saying that he was planning a similar, although smaller, event here in town. I'm so psyched.

And THEN, because what would happen if a day went by without Andrea volunteering for some half-baked scheme, I volunteered to help organize a bike-yoga-bike event in town. We'll ride our bikes to some park or field, or, perchance to dream, yoga studio, do some yoga, get back on our bikes, and come home. It sounds pretty much like heaven to me.

So... I did not change the world today. I did not save blighted countries, neighborhoods, or desperate people. I didn't even do any battles with dust bunnies or laundry. But I rode my little red bike, didn't drive my car anywhere, and had a great day.

Tags:

Monday, June 26, 2006

Well now, here's a thing

Sometimes I am very slow to catch on. The background is this. Next school year is the long-suffering spouse's year for a sabbatical. He made some career sacrifices in order to get our children through school without student loans. Now that's done, and he can get back to teaching and research -and he's counting the hours. He really needs the freedom to hit the ground running with this sabbatical year.

The other part of this family drama would be... you know... ME! Obviously, I could go with him. But, I would have to leave my friends, the parish, my job, and my support system to just hang out for a year. Andrea with nothing to do is not a pretty sight. He would have traded dependent children for a dependent wife -not an attractive trade for him and certainly not an attractive proposition for me to consider. I've done a certain amount of ranting about the essentially sexist nature of sabbaticals. The thinking seems to be that the non-sabbatical partner can uproot herself while the sabbatical-ing partner is free to think great thoughts. (I do see that the genders could be reversed; this affects my rants not in the slightest.)

Last Sunday, I had the brainstorm that this could be a transformative year for me as well. What if I slipped away for a year of service somewhere? Internationally... domestically... it makes no difference to me. For that matter, I could stay in the house and do some work in Chicago, while still taking the year to re-envision my life's mission. OK, "re-envisioning mission" is a little grandiose, I suppose, but it's close to the point.

I mentioned this to the spousal unit, and his comment was "I was wondering why you weren't thinking of this." Ummmm.... say something????? The light was a little slow in dawning, I have to say. But now, there's the possibility of an interesting year all my very own.

Friday, June 23, 2006

The Wrestling Coach from Yorkville

.... otherwise known as the Speaker of the House and my representative. (His mother calls him Denny Hastert.) He is in deep this time.

There are a few things you have to know before this story will make sense. Chicago is big. Okay, you probably knew that part. I meant it's geographically big, not just in terms of population. And, it's extending unevenly, but certainly, into the cornfields at its edge. As the population shifts and grows, transportation needs change. Denny Hastert lives a little west of Chicago, representing the corn counties.

That's the local color. The Washington connection is that, in 2005, the House of Representatives approved an extension of the interstate system, the Prairie Parkway, which will link two major highways, giving those of us out here in the fields another path to Chicago. Three months later, Dennis Hastert sold part of a farm, purchased in his wife's name, and an adjoining parcel held in trust between Hastert and some long-time supporters, to developers for a $1.8 million profit. This farm-land is 5.5 miles from the Prairie Parkway path.

Naturally, there was no disclosure of any financial interest in the appropriations for the new interstate. Naturally, he's claiming that he's entitled to this profit and that there was no need to disclose anything. Besides, how could 5 miles from a new interstate make a difference in the value of his land? Uh huh....

Land is increasing in value in Kendall Country. I'm not surprised that he could make a profit like that. I AM surprised that he's angry that the Tribune broke the story. I AM surprised that he clearly thinks - or wants us to think- that this is no big deal.

Tags:

Thursday, June 22, 2006

Friday Random 10




Here it is: the easiest and arguably best post of the week. You know the game. Set your iPod to shuffle mode and tell us the first 10 songs that appear. And no fair leaving out ones that make you look like a dork or adding in ones you think (however erroneously) will help you to look cool.

Here's my list:
  • Angel of the Morning; Juice Newton (Oh my. We're off to a good start.)
  • Ave Maria; Still Pointe (excellent! SOMEONE has some class in this joint!)
  • Meditation from Thais; Massenet by way of Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra (sentimental clap-trap, but this is MY iPod. You expected something else???)
  • Shima Shima; Deva Premal (Andrea trying vainly for some meditative composure. Tomorrow? World peace. Stay tuned.)
  • Riding My Bike; John McCutcheon (....the most wonderful feeling I've ever had/ I'm riding/ I'm falling/ I'm riding my bike!)
  • Sweet Home Alabama; Lynyrd Skynyrd (Well, obviously THAT has to be somewhere on my pod-ling.)
  • Rondeau; Jean-Joseph Mouret (and where is Alastaire Cooke when you need him?)
  • How Bad Do You Want It; Tim McGraw (Well now... I'll have to know you a lot better before I answer THAT question!)
  • The Littlest Snowman/ Captain Kangaroo (OH GOD! Proof that I don't edit these lists!!)
  • Don't Call Me Baby; Madison Avenuie (Indeed! Do not.)


Dear Defense Department, Study War No More

But for the love of all things decent, study SOMETHING!

Picture me, like Charlie Brown sitting at his desk, thunking his head on his desk in frustration. It seems that the Department of Defense believes that homosexuality is a "mental disorder." Here's the story:Common Dreams News Center. And they're qualified to make that claim because.... why, exactly? Yet, claim it they do.

There's a list of disqualifying impairments for admission to the armed forces. Mental impairments include conditions such as mental retardation, personality disorders, and homosexuality. Never mind that it's been more than 30 years since the mental health community removed homosexuality from the DSM, and it's embarrassing enough that it took so long for us to do it.

Two points come to mind immediately. First, they could make the "whoops.... outdated language" claim. Really, it's the only face-saving strategy I can see. Yet, it can't be true. If it were true, they wouldn't have the peculiar "don't ask, don't tell" policy. The military clearly knows that there are gay and lesbian soldiers; as long as they're quiet about it, same-sex orientation is a practical impediment to neither admission nor service. So, why put homosexuality on the list of mental impairments? It's hard to avoid the conclusion that there's something darker at work here.

Secondly, there are social workers, therapists, psychiatrists, and academics on the military's payroll. And even if there weren't, there are libraries in Washington. Go find a copy of the DSM. There's probably one lying around somewhere. Admittedly, it's a flawed and politically dangerous document itself. I'm not arguing its perfection, heaven knows. I am arguing that not consulting it suggests that you think you're experts in a field that isn't yours. Sensible .... I don't know.... botanists consult doctors when they have broken bones. Sensible physicists consult historians (or the published work of one) when they need information or perspectives about ancient Greece. There's nothing threatening about admitting that you don't know every single thing there is to know. Unless, of course, your intentions are more sinister than I would like to believe.

My final point isn't actually a critique of the military's reasoning. Well, not exactly. One is, of course, reminded of the Catholic Church's language of "objective disorder" regarding homosexuality. Just to be clear, I hate that language. Yes, I understand that it's rendered more horrifying in translation and that there are caveats aplenty. (Really, there are only a paltry few caveats. I'm trying to make the argument as easy as possible for the opposing point of view.) Hate still isn't too strong a word to describe my feelings.

Nonetheless, a church doesn't claim to represent the whole society and the whole society doesn't pay for its existence. A church could even properly claim to be counter-cultural, as in going against prevailing cultural norms. (Well, a church could properly claim to be counter-cultural in the more popular understanding of the term, too. But they rarely do.) So, the Catholic Church's claim that homosexuality is a disorder is an internal discussion waiting to be had. The military, which is a function of the broader society, making the same claim is a different enterprise altogether.

Wednesday, June 21, 2006

Death Be Not Proud


My heart just bleeds for the two U.S. soldiers found dead from torture. It falls out of my chest and bleeds on the floor. I try to comfort myself thus... In this allegedly all-volunteer army, they signed up. On some level, one hopes they knew the risks and that they took comfort in the certainty that their comrades were searching for them. Their families didn't sign up and couldn't possibly have been prepared. And even worse, they have to keep living, knowing what their sons endured. I think I'd go stark raving mad, in their shoes.

There is only one thing that would make this situation worse. And my fear is that it's not just likely but inevitable. If we use this atrocity to continue torturing other people's children, we avenge nothing. If we use this inhumane act to lower ourselves -again- to the level of barbaric torturers, nothing changes for the good. And if, in some tragic twist of logic and compassion, doing exactly those things becomes an expression of patriotism and even piety, then I won't know us at all.

Monday, June 19, 2006

The President's Netflix Queue

Arianna Huffington (not my favorite blogger, by a long shot) had an interesting editorial on Saturday. Apparently Bush's great idea to create the world's largest marine protected area (the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands Monument)came from watching a Jean-Michel Cousteau documentary. So, that naturally causes the question to arise, what else should we slip into the president's netflix queue? Ms. Huffington has some ideas, but really.... there are more.

  • The Great Dictator
  • Fahrenheit 911
  • Wag the Dog
  • Artificial Intelligence (Manhattan flooded by the melted polar ice caps...
  • The Truman Show (would he get the parallels to warrantless eavesdropping, I wonder?)
  • Monster's Ball (Okay it's not really the main point of the movie, but maybe he'd have to think about the costs of capital punishment for the people left behind
  • American Beauty (Surely THAT would make him rethink the necessary sanctity of the one man-one woman marriage.)
  • Bowling for Columbine
  • The American President
  • Dave
  • Gandhi
  • Mr. Smith Goes to Washington


But really.... if we want to give him ideas, we have to go with All the President's Men -but we have to make sure he gets all the way to end.

And we really ought to come up with a summer reading list for him, as well. It's time for him to move beyond The Very Hungry Caterpillar, don't you think?

Friday, June 16, 2006

Friday Random 10


You know the game. Set your iPod to shuffle mode and tell us the first ten songs that appear. And no fair leaving out the ones that make you look like a dork or adding in ones that you think make you look cool

For the record, I always learn something during this little exercise. Sometimes it's fun, sometimes embarrassing. Mostly it's unimportant trivia (as in, I have more country music on my iPod than I would have thought possible), but it's always interesting -to me, anyway. Try it; see what happens!

Here's my list for the week:
  • You Are the Presence; David Haas
  • All Fired Up; Pat Benatar
  • Walking in Memphis; Marc Cohn
  • Dear Mr. President; Pink and Indigo Girls
  • Baby Be Brave; The Corrs
  • The Trouble with Boys; Little Eva
  • Girl on a Bicycle; Ralph McTell
  • One Girl Revolution; Superchick
  • Child of Mine; Emmylou Harris
  • Good People All; Anonymous 4


Thursday, June 15, 2006

Popcorn and Social Change


We haven't done this in a while and the Human Rights Watch International Film Festival is in New York this month. So, we should give movies that support social change some attention, perhaps. Bear in mind, I have seen precisely one of these movies, so I have no reason to recommend them, exactly. I have had great luck, though, using their movies as my movies, so if that's any encouragement for you... there it is. Here's the link to the schedule: International Film Festival.

I'm particularly interested in:

I've seen Amu, which they're showing next Friday. It's well worth seeing.After the "read more" goes here.

Wednesday, June 14, 2006

The Cuckoo's Nest


The military already compromises the integrity of mental health professionals and the principles of ethical encounters with the service delivery system. That's not news. Ask anyone who's ever sought even the least threatening of mental health services and also wanted to join the military. It won't happen. My personal theory is that we should provide -possibly even require- mental health services for all armed services personnel. But that would make too much sense. And, we've just taken yet another turn into the surreal.

Now mental health professionals (and other health professionals as well) can be used as torturers. I'm hardly exaggerating. There's a new Department of Defense directive issued by Assistant Secretary of Health Affairs, William Winkenwerder, Jr, making mental health professionals part of the interrogation teams for detainees in U.S. custody. The new policy explicitly allows mental health information from clinical encounters to be used as part of an interrogation, violating the ethical principle of confidentiality. The new directive also instructs health professionals regarding hunger strikes, requiring force-feeding of prisoners protesting their confinement by denying themselves nutrition. You can find the directive here: DoD directives. Interestingly, they've taken down the revised version. I wonder what that means; the slightly older one is there, however.

And the situation gets even more interesting. Not even a month ago, the American Psychological Association and the World Medical Association (of which the AMA is a member), issued ethical guidelines prohibiting the participation of member professionals in interrogations -period. The idea being that the only way to protect the role of healer is to separate it from inflicting torture. Kind of obvious, really. You can read the APA's statement about participation in torture here: APA. So, what's going to happen? The military will be using professionals who can't be members of the appropriate professional organization? I suppose there are worse things. The professionals will certainly have to choose which authority is the more important one to follow -and it will probably be the one that puts food on the table and clothes their children. And (or?) ethical professionals will leave military service. Leaving... whom???

You can read the Physicians for Human Rights statement denouncing the new policy here: Physicians for Human Rights There's also a petition to Congress to end the participation of mental health professionals in torture. You can read more and sign on, if you like, here: The Ignacio Martin-Baro Fund.

Monday, June 12, 2006

Self-harm as a Publicity Stunt?

That's what we're supposed to believe, apparently. Colleen Graffy, U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for public diplomacy (let me repeat that part... diplomacy!) said of the three suicides at Guantanamo, "it was a good PR move." Further, "It does sound that this is part of a strategy in that they don't value their own life and they certainly don't value ours and they use suicide bombings as a tactic to further their Jihadi cause." Elegantly done, Colleen. Now the British press -and I remind you that Britain is our closest ally in this demented war- is calling these and other comments "cold and odious." Diplomacy, indeed.

Yet the truth that the comments were indelicate and ill-advised is not the biggest story here. We need to keep coming back to the other truth that people have been sitting in that prison for four years, with no charges brought against them, no trial dates, and no end in sight. On some very low level you can almost sympathize with Ms. Graffy. Making absurd claims about this situation is the only possibility here; it's the situation itself that is surreal.

Mental health professionals and scholars know a little bit about self-harm in prison. Even making the argument as easy as possible for the administration, Guantanamo comes off as ethically indefensible and sociologically ineffective. It's torture, and it degrades us all, in other words. But I'm equally disappointed in scholars and practitioners who haven't exactly been exercising moral or intellectual leadership here. Let's see what we have.

Let's say the detainees were overtly manipulative of the guards, threatening suicide when they didn't intend to do it just to get attention and cause trouble. Some prisoners do that. However, there's at least one study that rejects the notion that manipulative prisoners and prisoners at risk of suicide are mutually exclusive groups. Try this link, if you're interested: Dear, Thomson, and Hills. Guards must take suicide threats seriously, whether or not they believe them -assuming of course that suicide prevention is the goal. So that argument doesn't work.

Let's try something different. Let's say that these prisoners were so dangerous that extended solitary confinement is the only possibility in order to ensure the safety of the guards. Psychiatric literature since the 19th century documents the link between mental aberrations, including psychosis, and solitary confinement. The longer you hold someone in psychologically dangerous conditions, the more likely that person is to have a psychotic break. Self-harm and harm of others are almost equally likely, so that argument doesn't work either.

The thing I really can't wrap my brain around is that if the administration thought these people were guilty of something, they'd want a trial -and a very public one, at that. So that can't be it. Maybe they do think that the detainees have information that they need. But the advisors must have access to the same information that I do. Well, of course they do; a google-scholar search is good enough. And that search will reveal that information gleaned through torture is notoriously unreliable. If google-scholar is too erudite (???), try the Army Field Manual which states "Army interrogation experts view the use of force as an inferior technique that yields information of questionable quality (Sec. 4A3)."

But here's the thing that googling obscures. The academic debate has been largely off the point as well, I think. There has been a steady parade of academics on the mainstream press and through the White House gates indicating that torture in catastrophic circumstances is morally permissible, if there's reasonable cause to believe that a greater evil might be prevented. We need to challenge the arguments for "principled torture", no matter the legal justification. The narrow framework of that discussion obscures the realities of torture and sets up a false choice between protecting human rights and preventing a terrorist attack. Where are the principled academics????

Now that I think about it, where are the spiritual leaders?


Friday, June 09, 2006

Friday Random 10


You know the game! Take out your iPod and set it to shuffle mode. Then tell us the first ten songs that appear. And no fair leaving out ones that make you look like a dork -or adding in ones that you think will repair the damage. Here's my list for the week:

  • In My Mother's House; Kate Campbell (I am a prodigal daughter/but in my wandering I have found/there is a wideness in mercy/and there'll always be a place for me/in my mother's house)
  • How Dad Created the World; Trapezoid (for a Father's Day playlist I'm putting together for the long-suffering spouse)
  • What's Love Got to Do with It; Tina Turner
  • Viens, Mallika/Lakme; Delibes
  • Hallelujah; Leonard Cohen (an aural orgasm)
  • Windhorse; Bill Douglas
  • Someone Else's Dream; Faith Hill
  • We Shall Overcome; Pete Seeger (Oh come on... you KNEW I had this one.)
  • Peace Tonight; Indigo Girls
  • Wondrous Love; Anonymous 4


Thursday, June 08, 2006

Now I'm an "Abortion Lady"????

Ann Coulter just irritates the crap out of me. I suppose that's no surprise. I used to think that the pretty girl of reactionary politics was actually intelligent, and it was a shame that she is such a poor steward of that gift, using sound bite and dismissive "reasoning" as she does. Now I just think she's a mean-spirited, attention-seeking narcissist.

I can NOT bring myself to make a link to her latest book, Godless. I think my fingers would fall off. But in it, she argues that abortion is the highest sacrament of liberalism and that "the abortion ladies" want legal abortions so that we can have consequence-free sexual trysts.

Yeah, that's it. My life is just a series of wild sexual flings. (Sarcasm there, in case you missed it.) I think I missed the announcement that they were available! Oh well. And there are, in her little world, no pro-choice men? And it couldn't be that we want women to have real choice and control over what happens to their bodies? It couldn't be that we trust women to make wise and prudent decisions? It couldn't be that we want every child to be wanted? It couldn't be that we don't celebrate abortion, but choice?

The thing is, she knows all that. She must. And she chooses to say something different anyway. And as a self-proclaimed evangelical Christian with Jesus whispering in her ear, she knows the name for that. And the fact that it's a sin against the eighth commandment (or the 9th, depending on how you want to count them).

Wednesday, June 07, 2006

Repeat After Me, Mr. Bush.....

Religion is not a weapon of the state. Now keep saying it until you get it.

The Supreme Court in Iowa gets it, so there are signs of intelligent life in the heartland. (More later on my theory that we in the "fly-over states" are going to be essential in the next round of elections.) The Iowa Supreme Court ruled that a state-funded evangelical prison ministry violates the Constitutional separation of church and state. Well, yeah. You can get the story here: NYT.

There are several interesting bits to this. First, actual people had to care enough to bring the case to trial. The legal system doesn't exist solely in a world of ideas; someone has to take action. In this situation, the case was filed by Americans United for Separation of Church and State. So, people are paying attention and taking action. Excellent. Secondly, the case sets the stage for a broader consideration of the Bush administration's strong commitment to faith-based services. I've ranted about this before, and it's way overdue in my never-humble opinion.

And here's the thing -the place where I might actually have a contribution to make. It's pretty obvious, I suppose, that I'm a faithful person (with issues around religious expression, but I'm working on it. Really.) who also knows a thing or two about service delivery. I absolutely concede -and celebrate- the fact that faith can inspire people to be good and to do good. But forcing people to follow the forms of religion isn't good religion or good social service practice. It doesn't work on either end. People end up with insipid faith and nondescript recovery skills. And the taxpayers have paid for this. Moreover -and I suppose it's less important, but it's still irritating- the stereotype of faithful people as coercive and intellectually bankrupt is perpetuated. Hmmm... I think I've ranted about that before, too. I'm shutting up now.

Tuesday, June 06, 2006

Get Your Paws Off My Language

I grant you, this is just a meaningless rant. You'll have to visit someone else's blog if you want something constructive today. Here's the thing. I'm not completely fussy about grammar and usage. I sometimes intentionally split infinitives, start sentences with conjunctions, and use too many commas. I have to remind myself how to spell "embarrass," and I've embarrassed myself on more than one occasion when I didn't stop to think how to spell it. But give me a break.

I went to technorati this morning. The site will tell you what the top ten most popular search tags are. You know what makes the top ten? "Loose weight", that's what. Spelled correctly, it doesn't make the top ten. This disturbs me. Or is "loose weight" something distinct from "tight weight" and I'm just out of the loop on this new phenomenon? Then, I opened my e-mail. There I found a completely meaningless sentence that starts "Thank you for taking the imitative...". Taking the what? I'm sorry you've lost your imitative, but I didn't take it. Eventually I figured out what the writer meant, but really, the reader should only have to do half the work of communication.

And then I went to the grocery store because we're out of coffee (undoubtedly the actual cause of my cantankerous rant). Since I had only one item in my cart, I lined up in the "10 items or less" line. Blast it! Are the anti-grammarians out to get me today?

Sunday, June 04, 2006

Requiescat in Pace

A dear friend has died. Mary Uscian was -and will continue to be- a source of light and hope to her friends and to the community. She was a nurse who made sure poor people received health care. With a friend, she started the local sliding-scale medical clinic. She made sure there were health screenings at the shelter for homeless people.

But more than what she did, there was just who she was. She was hilariously funny, quick-witted, deeply spiritual, but also justly critical of (and wounded by) the Catholic Church.

I'm having trouble with tenses as I write. It's hard to remember to write "was" rather than "is". The news is still fresh feeling, and I'm in that phase where it's hard to grasp the finality of her death. We'll really never see her again. That's just wrong.

Please hold her (and she'd want me to say, everyone who works for justice) in your thoughts and prayers today. The world still needed Mary. There's some comfort that she's no longer suffering from her brutal illness. But it's not quite enough, yet.

Saturday, June 03, 2006

Mapping Our Rights

A new website tracks reproductive and sexual rights by state. Ipas, the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, and SisterSong Women of Color Reproductive Health Collective collaborated to come up with a database evaluating access to abortion and contraception, LGBT issues, and other concerns such as abstinence-only sex education programs. (I am reliably informed that the mathematics behind such an enterprise is interesting and complex. After that, my eyes glazed over.)

It's easy to see how your own state ranks on these issues, but there's more information tucked in the data available here. For example, there seems to be a clear positive correlation between states with abstinence-only sex education and with high teen pregnancy rates. We knew this, of course, but here's some data to support what we expected.

Go here to see the U.S. map: Sexual Rights Map. Click on your state to get more in-depth information. (You are going to have to recognize the shape of your state. Please don't let this turn into a rant about the state of geographical literacy and the quality of education in this country.) Then let me know what you're thinking!


Friday, June 02, 2006

We Know Not What We Do....


I'm heart-sick and disgusted. In keeping with June's focus as anti-torture month, I've just listened to former Army Chaplain James Yee's account of his time at Guantanamo. The quick recap is that he was the U.S. Army Muslim chaplain to the detainees at Guantanamo. He was accused of being a spy, threatened with the death penalty, put into solitary confinement, and tortured. Until the charges were dropped. Whoops. You can read a transcript of an interview he gave on this subject at Democracy Now.

And, not that it really matters, James Yee is a U.S. citizen from a career military family. Torture isn't just happening to "those other guys". Yee has written a book recounting his experiences: For God and Country: Faith and Patriotism Under Fire. It's well worth a look. For one thing, he understands (as I hope I never have to) that it really is patriotism under fire. This...thing... that Bush calls patriotism or defending the country or keeping us strong, that's not patriotism. Patriotism calls us to something more noble, more courageous in defending our principles, and substantially less craven than torturing people.

Moreover, our version of patriotism reminds us that we are the government. And since no one in the official government has apologized to Mr. Yee for his uncalled-for detention and torture, I will. We all should.

Mr. Yee, I'm very sorry that this happened to you. I'm very sorry that you were tortured by people claiming to act for me. If it's any consolation at all, your experience has moved me to take action to ensure that someone remembers what real patriotism is.

You can blog against torture too. It's not enough, but it's an important start. Join us here: Blog Against Torture.

Biker-Boy Sighting

Using my extensive network of nun-friends and priests-Andrea-has-dated (stop it... mommies weren't always mommies and priests weren't always priests!), I know that biker-boy is alive and well and somewhere in South Dakota. In keeping with his perspective that bike time is retreat time, he's been staying at retreat centers and monastery/convent guest houses.

So, the good people at Benedictine Peace Center have given rest to the weary traveler. It looks beautiful. I know there are political reasons for not spending your disposable income travel-dollars in South Dakota, but this is really tempting. Two points here, though.....

One problem with priests and nuns (from my perspective), is that it never occurs to them to ask "Have you called your wife?". They are generous and gracious in offering hospitality, but the whole thing about other people worrying is just outside their experience. And you just KNOW that biker-boy isn't going to think of it.

And for a geometer, this boy has a peculiar sense of circularity. He "forgot" to turn around, apparently, and head for home. Unfortunately, the calendar keeps marching forward as well, and the date he needs to be back here hasn't changed. So now the plan is to just keep riding until he finds an Amtrak station and to take the train home. Perhaps my joke that the academy protects people who would otherwise be in a different (and arguably less pleasant) kind of institution isn't so far off after all!

But he'll be home soon. God speed, dear one!

Friday Random 10


You know the drill. Take out your iPod and set it to shuffle mode. Tell us the first ten songs that appear. And no fair leaving out the ones that make you look like a dork or adding in ones that make you look cool.

Here are mine for this week:
  • Music for the Royal Fireworks -Prelude; Handel
  • Miss Clare Remembers; Enya
  • New Attitude; Patti LaBelle
  • How Beautiful; Still Pointe (It is a beautiful song.)
  • The Honor of Your Company; Tom Paxton
  • Volcano; Jimmy Buffett
  • Music in my Mother's House; Ronnie Gilbert and Holly Near
  • Symphony No. 9 in E minor -Adagio; Dvorak
  • To Everyone in the World; Cathy Fink
  • Come to Us, O Emmanuel; Gary Daigle and Marty Haugen


Thursday, June 01, 2006

Sex Cults????

There's been lots of blogging and ranting about the FDA and its refusal to approve the emergency contraception Plan B. I've also blogged myself about how a different bit of the federal government is being taken over by faith-based policy-makers who only want to fund what they deem to be be righteous. So... here we are again.

Acting FDA Deputy Commissioner for Operations, Janet Woodcock (could I possibly have made that up???) has these fears about Plan B: "we could not anticipate or prevent extreme promiscuous behaviors such as the medication taking on an 'urban legend' status that would lead adolescents to form sex-based cults centered around the use of Plan B." You couldn't anticipate it or you clearly do anticipate it? If you can anticipate it, why can't you prevent (or at least mitigate) it? And sex cults based on teenagers' misinformation about sex? Have you actually met any teenagers? They don't need cults to spread misinformation or to be fixated on sex. What's so horrible about giving them (or... you know.... adult women) the option of not conceiving?

So, okay, she's just blathering. I do a certain amount of that myself. What's really the problem here? Plan B contraception has nothing to do with a fertilized egg. It works by preventing the ovaries from releasing an egg for a short while, so there is nothing to fertilize. Therefore, the typical pro-life fertilized-egg-as-baby argument has nothing to do with this situation. So that's not it. And if we're not protecting babies, what are we doing?

Really, is there an option other than controlling women? I can't think of one, and I tried. And controlling women through our reproductive potential is hardly news, especially when you link it to the recent news from the CDC that all women between menarche and menopause should treat themselves as pre-pregnant and take prenatal vitamins. As my friend Elisa says (sarcastically), "the health of a potential fetus should be your priority if you're a woman."


Just..... yuck.